Tuesday, May 31, 2016

A Few Questions

These are some questions that I asked a Church-of-Christ preacher after reading an article that he wrote. I don't recall ever getting an answer from him:

Mr -----,
Here are a few questions that I have concerning information in one of your blog posts:

1. Why did God create us in the New Testament scenario, if he knew all would sin, and knew that the many vs the few would eternally perish (Mt. 7:13-14)?  2 Peter 3:9 says that it is not God's will that ANY perish. Did God not have the ability to achieve his will that none perish?

2. If God is omniscient and could see what would happen if he created Satan, why would he go ahead and create Satan knowing that in his attempt to be victorious over Satan, billions of humans would have to eternally perish?

3. Why would God, who doesn't need man (Acts 17:25), nevertheless, go ahead and create man to get some things that he only wanted (victory over Satan, whom he didn't have to create; fear and obedience from man; companionship from man, etc.), but didn't need, knowing that to get these things that he didn't need, billions of sentient humans would have to eternally perish?

4. You said that Jesus [dying] on the cross, ...sealed the greatest victory possible. But how could this be considered "the greatest  victory possible" when Satan deceives the whole world (Rev 12:9), disguises himself as an angel of light (2 Cor 11:14), and blinds the minds of the unbelieving ( 2 Cor 4:4), resulting in Jesus losing the majority of souls to Satan (Mt 7:13-14)?

5. You said that man is a "tool" by which God gets glory. But God doesn't need anything from man, thus he doesn't need glory. Why would God put his beloved(?), flawed humans under the influence of such a powerful being for evil as Satan (whom he didn't have to create) to get something that wasn't necessary--knowing that to get this glory that he doesn't need, billions of sentient humans would have to eternally perish?

Well, I've got a lot more questions I could ask. But I'll stop for now. You've got a lot on your plate with these five.

Ken Hawthorne

Friday, May 20, 2016

The Absence Of Positive Evidence

What does the absence of positive evidence for an
extraordinary claim mean? Farrell Till answers this
important question. From the Errancy Discussion 
list, 2-15-99:

You just can't seem to understand this principle, can you? The absence of positive evidence that the virgin birth of Jesus happened does not constitute proof that it did NOT happen; however, given the extraordinary nature of the claim, the absence of positive evidence that it happened does constitute legitimate reasons not to believe that it happened. If you can't see the difference, then you need more help than I can give you, Matt.

Let's take the Muslim claim that Muhammad divided the moon into two parts. The absence of positive evidence that this event happened does not constitute negative evidence, i.e., evidence that it did NOT happen. However, given the extraordinary nature of the claim, the absence of positive evidence that it happened constitutes very legitimate reasons not to believe that it happened.

Friday, May 13, 2016

Playing The Odds

From TSR, March/April 1991:

by Farrell Till 
If I am right and you are wrong...." How many times have bibliolaters said this to skeptics after all rational efforts to defend the Bible have failed? What they are saying is that one should believe the Bible in order to be on the safe side, just in case it really is God's inspired word. This argument, if that is what they intend it to be, is merely a variation of Pascal's wager, a theistic argument made famous by the French philosopher Blaise Pascal. "If you gain, you gain all," Pascal argued. "If you lose, you lose nothing. Wager, then, without hesitation that He is."

Aside from the obvious fact that one cannot believe--sincerely believe--a thing just to be on the safe side, the absurdity of Pascal's wager is seen in the utter impossibility of practicing it. One should believe in God just in case God really does exist. Okay, what next? After one wagers on God's existence, what religion does he choose to practice his faith in God? Does he become a Christian or a Moslem? A Zoroastrian or a Hindu? If he chooses Christianity, what brand of it does he select? If he becomes a Methodist, how does he deal with the possibility that Catholicism may be the true religion? To meet the requirements of Pascal's wager, one would have to simultaneously become a believer in all religions in the world, and this would be utterly impossible, since many religions forbid beliefs in others.

A Fallacious Tear-Jerking Scenario (2)

From the Errancy Discussion list, 9-11-97:

NANCY
Yes, Matt. What one *can* do and what one *does* do are two different things. That is why I find the xtian god so damned abhorent. He could prevent innocent children from suffering, but he chooses not to. He could have made himself known to everyone, and thus have saved countless millions from the neverending torment *he* chooses to impose upon those he is supposed to love, yet he prefers to torture his creation. He made his  own son suffer for the sins of others even though he is perfectly capable of forgiving sins without human sacrifice. The only reasonable conclusion to draw is that the xtian god is a sadistic bastard who gets his jollies from human suffering. If a human stands idly by while others suffer or causes others to suffer, as the xtian god does, we call him a heartless, inhuman monster. Perhaps we should just call him God.

MATT
What would you do if your son/daughter was being raped by a group of men. Intervene or stand back and watch?

TILL
I'd intervene, but let me head Matt off at the pass to show him that what he probably has in mind is going to work against him.  He probably intends to say that God didn't intervene when his "son" was being killed by a mob, and so that shows how much he loved humankind. If that is what he has in mind, let him take note that he has just proven our point. The anthropomorphic imagery of a "heavenly Father" grieving over the suffering and death of his son is shown to be nonsense, because any ananthropomorphic father who had the power to do so would prevent a mob from killing his son. Since the "heavenly Father" didn't do this, he is undeniably unlike earthly fathers. Therefore, it is fallacious to reason that the "heavenly Father" suffered grief as an earthly father would have done in the same circumstances.

Farrell Till

A Fallacious Tear-Jerking Scenario (1)

From the Errancy Discussion list, 9-10-97: 

TILL
Even the suffering angle is fallacious. If Jesus was himself God, then he too was omniscient and omnipotent, so he had nothing to fear during his trial and crucifixion, because he knew that he wasn't really going to die. If he had all power, then he could have anesthetized himself so that he wouldn't feel anything, so if he suffered any pain, it was his own fault. Furthermore, how could a preacher know that "pain" would be the same to a god, whose ways are always higher than man's ways? This whole tear-jerking scenario is too ridiculous for words. 

MATT
I could not hold off responding to this post by you any longer Till :) What is ridiculous is your complete misunderstanding of what is claimed happened to Christ on the cross, and what the sufferings of Christ involved. Suggest you learn what Christians believe this was as you obviously do not have a clue based on your above comment. Once you have educated yourself on this perhaps you would consider retracting the last line of your above post as being down to your ignorance of Christianity rather than a true representation of the same.

TILL
What exactly have you answered? You remind me of a couple of Christian airheads that I am having exchanges with on another list. They claim that they don't have to explain or prove anything because their faith is sufficient enough to show that they are right. My contention is that the anthropomorphic nonsense about a "heavenly father" grieving over the death of his son is completely idiotic, because it offers no explanation of why an omniscient, omnipotent deity who would know that his "son" was eternal would have any reason to experience grief that could be compared to an earthly father whose son is killed. Blame yourself and not me for the stupidity of this scenario. To be blunt about it, Matt, who gives a rat's ass what Christians believe? The issue is not what Christians believe but whether what Christians believe is logically defensible.

Farrell Till

Tuesday, April 12, 2016

Disinterested Testimony

The following is from the Errancy Discussion list from
1-13-98. Farrell Till explains the term, "disinterested". 
Till convincingly argues that this is the type of 
testimony that is needed in order to give us sufficient 
reason to believe that the apostles and Jesus Christ 
actually existed. But, sadly, this type of testimony 
is conspicuously missing (please excuse the transcription 
quality):



Sayeedul Islam wrote:

I wanted to know exactly what you meant by 
"disinterested source"? I don't really know 
if you mean a source that has no inclination 
towards either side of a discussion or if 
you mean something else. I personally don't 
believe there is any historical writing that 
has ever been written without some sort of a 
bias or perspective. Please clarify. 

TILL
In English the word "disinterested" means "free of 
bias and self-interest, impartial, or indifferent."  
You are undoubtedly right when you say that probably 
no historical writing has ever been written without 
some sort of a bias or perspective, but relatively 
speaking, one can evaluate records to determine if 
they are fundamentally free of bias.  Let's take, 
for example,the testimony of the 11 Mormon witnesses, 
who signed affidavits swearing that they either 
saw the angel Moroni deliver golden plates to Joseph 
Smith or else saw and handled the plates.  However, 
these witnesses were known to be leaders and adherents 
of the newly proclaimed Mormon faith.  Even when we
look at their names, we can immediately see reasons 
to be suspicious of their testimony. Five of the eleven, 
for example, had the surname Whitmer, an indication 
that they were probably all related to David Whitmer, 
another one of the witnesses and a leader in the 
Mormon movement. Three of them had the surname Smith, 
one of whom was Joseph Smith, Sr., the father of the 
man who allegedly received the special revelation 
from God. These facts about the witnesses exclude 
them from all possibility of being considered 
disinterested witnesses.



When we examine religious literature as a whole, we
see very little indication that these writings were 
produced by disinterested parties. The writers of 
the NT, for example, were obviously adherents of the 
Christian faith, and their intention in writing was 
not to produce accurate historical records of  what 
they wrote about. They wanted to further the cause of
Christianity, and the writer of John's gospel came 
right out and admitted that this was his purpose: 
"Many other signs therefore did Jesus in the presence 
of his disciples, which are not written in this book, 
but these are written that you may believe that Jesus 
is the Christ, the Son of God, and that believing you 
may have life in his name" (20:30-31). Such writings as
this cannot by any stretch of imagination be considered 
"disinterested testimony."

Goodguy has sarcastically compared my questioning the 
historicity of the apostles to questioning the 
historicity of Napoleon, but the two are not comparable. 
There are disinterested records of Napoleon. If documents 
produced in a country that was hostile to Napoleon 
referred to him, then it would be safe to assume that 
the authors of the documents were not trying to further 
any of Napoleon's political causes. Hence, we can 
consider this disinterested testimony to Napoleon's 
existence.  In calling disinterested testimony basically 
reliable, I am not establishing any standards that I 
am not willing to apply to the Bible.  The Babylonian 
Chronicle refers independently of the Bible to 
Nebuchadnezzar and details some events that are 
recorded in the books of Kings and Chronicles about 
this Babylonian king; hence, it becomes reasonable 
to accept the historicity of Nebuchadnezzar because 
independent confirmation of the biblical record is 
known to exist.  The Bible tells the story of Jehu, 
a king of Israel, in 2 Kings 9-10 and 2 
Chronicles 22. Jehu's historical existence can be 
reasonably accepted, because the archaeological 
discovery of the Black Obelisk of Assyria provides 
independent confirmation of Jehu's reign.  The
Obelisk pictures a king bearing tribute to 
Shalmaneser III, and an inscription says that this 
was "the tribute of Jehu, son of Omri." The Bible 
mentions King Mesha of Moab in 2 Kings 3, and the 
discovery of the Moabite Stone revealed a narrative 
attributed to King Mesha; hence, this would 
constitute confirmation independent of the Bible record.  
There are other examples that I could cite, but these 
should be sufficent to show the difference between
disinterested, independent confirmation of biblical
records and just the blind acceptance of anything the 
Bible says simply because it is in the Bible. This is 
the problem that confronts Goodguy in the present 
controversy over the apostles. He has no disinterested 
confirmation of his claim that the apostles died for 
their belief in the resurrection. All that he can do 
is cite what is said in biased records left by avowed 
Christian writers and highly improbable traditions.

Farrell Till

Friday, April 1, 2016

Exceptional Claims Require Exceptional Evidence


A short discussion between Farrell Till and a Christian, Brian, on 
the necessity of exceptional evidence for the exceptional claims of 
religionists--which never seem to materialize for some reason. From 
Alt. Bible Errancy discussion list, Jan. 2, 1999:

TILL
Please explain to us what is "monotonous" and "unscholarly 
cynical" about asking for reasonable evidence that exceptional 
claims are true. Muslims make exceptional claims about their 
religion. Hindus make exceptional claims about their religion. 
Mormons make exceptional claims about their religion. Is it
your position that such claims should be accepted without 
question? If not, then please explain to us why you think 
that your exceptional claims about the Bible should be accepted 
without question. In other words, what makes your exceptional 
claims so exceptional that they should be made exceptions to 
the widely recognized rule of evidence that says that exceptional 
claims require exceptional evidence? Would you do us a favor 
and actually try to answer an argument for a change?

BRIAN
Again, the SUBJECT of the discussion is religious war in the
name of GOd. Why don't you stop begging the question and 
answer it?

TILL
Your statement begs the very question of the existence of a 
god in whose name the religious war can be fought. At any
rate, although this may have been the subject of discussion, 
your comments on the subject constantly beg questions that 
you should try to prove before presenting them as assertions
apparently intended to prove your case. Therefore, it is 
appropriate to point out to you this logical fallacy that you
constantly resort to. The fact is that you can hardly write a 
sentence without resorting to question begging.

BRIAN
Because man is a liar and perverts God's truth through his sins,
does that make God a liar?

TILL
This statement confirms what I just said above. It begs the 
questions of (1) the existence of "God's truth," (2) the reality 
of sin, and (3) the existence of God.

Farrell Till