Sunday, October 30, 2011

A Quote From The Errancy List


This is a quote from the Errancy Discussion list from about two years ago:

Stuart Shepherd wrote:

"What arguments are there for the resurrection of Jesus? The empty tomb? If a corpse is missing do we assume that the person resurrected or do we try [to] find the guys who moved the body? The post resurrection appearances of Jesus? Jesus only showed himself to his own followers. History is full of amazing claims by groups where the only witnesses are members of the group. Nobody ever accepts these claims because they lack credibility.

There is no evidence that would stand up in a court of law. Unfortunately, Christians have been brainwashed by parents, friends, family, the media, their church, and their school."



Wednesday, October 19, 2011

Quote Of The Day


"It is wrong, always, everywhere, and for everyone, to believe anything upon insufficient evidence."  W.K. Clifford



Tuesday, October 11, 2011

Unreasonable Belief


The following is a comment by former Church-of-Christ preacher Farrell Till from his Errancy Discussion list from 1997, about the Bible's claim that Aaron and Moses followed Yahweh's command to inflict incredibly destructive plagues on Egypt in order to get Pharaoh to let the Israelite slaves go free. And that Pharaoh, unbelievably, had his own magicians attempt the same destructive plagues on his own people to prove that he was as powerful as Aaron and Moses' god (please see my comments in blue at the end):

It is unreasonable to believe that when Aaron and Moses changed all of the water throughout all the land of Egypt into blood, pharaoh's magicians would have done "likewise with their enchantments." Well, as I have already noted in an X but not X posting, it would have been a logical impossibility for the magicians to have done likewise with their enchantments, because there would have been no water left for them to change into blood. But if we assume that such a feat was logically possible, it was certainly a stupid act on pharaoh's part. If, for example, terrorists should contaminate all water east of the Mississippi with a deadly chemical, the president would be an idiot if he ordered his agents to do the same thing to all water west of the Mississippi. How idiotic! The story would have been more reasonable if the magicians had been presented as agents of pharaoh who undid the plagues that Aaron and Moses inflicted on Egypt.

Instead, we find this tit-for-tat premise in the story of the plagues. At the beginning whatever Aaron and Moses did, the magicians did likewise with their enchantments. A & M changed all of the water in Egypt into blood, and then the magicians somehow changed all of the water in Egypt into blood. A & brought forth the plague of frogs, and then the magicians brought forth even more frogs. Who can believe such nonsense? Why didn't the magicians show their power by taking away all of the frogs?

Farrell Till

At first thought one might wonder, why biblical inerrantists don't come up with insightful, reasonable thinking like this, but when one realizes the irrational thought process that they are working with--wanting to believe the Bible is inerrant and only looking for reasons to believe that it is inerrant, rather than simply looking for the truth--it's no wonder at all. (KWH)

Sunday, August 28, 2011

"Perfectly Fiendish"


The following is an excerpt from one of Robert Green Ingersoll's speeches from *Ingersoll--Black Debate on The Christian Religion* (1881):

A very curious thing about these [ten] commandments is that their supposed author violated nearly every one. From Sinai, according to the account, he said: "Thou shalt not kill," and yet he ordered the murder of millions; "Thou shalt not commit adultery," and yet he gave captured maidens to gratify the lust of captors; "Thou shalt not steal," and yet he gave to Jewish marauders the flocks and herds of others; "Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's house, nor his wife," and yet he allowed his chosen people to destroy the homes of neighbors and to steal their wives; "Honor thy father and thy mother," and yet this same God had thousands of fathers butchered, and with the sword of war killed children yet unborn; "Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbor," and yet he sent abroad "lying spirits" to deceive his own prophets, and in a hundred ways paid tribute to deceit. So far as we know, Jehovah kept only one of these commandments -- he worshiped no other god.

Wednesday, August 17, 2011

You Saw Whom Yesterday?


by Kenneth W. Hawthorne
No matter how much integrity a person has, it is not sufficient to prove a miracle claim. It is much more likely that the person claiming he witnessed a miraculous event had an error in judgment, is kidding, or even lying than that a miracle actually occurred. We believe this because, all around us all the time we see natural law taking place without  any interruption at all.

If a man tells me he saw Confederate General Robert E. Lee yesterday I immediately think he is either kidding me, that he is mistaken, or even possibly lying to me. For me to believe that he actually saw Robert E. Lee, in the flesh, the evidence would have to be of such an unequivocal, unimpeachable, convincing nature that I would have no choice but to believe it. No testimony even comes close to rising to that level. Whether it is testimony from a good friend from just yesterday about Robert E. Lee or much less from four anonymous writers from 2000 years ago about a man coming back to life after being dead for about  three days.

The only rational way to evaluate claims that one has no firsthand knowledge of is to apply a rule of evidence that Carl Lofmark explained in What Is The Bible?:
When you lack evidence, the only way to decide whether or not to believe something is to ask: Is it likely? If you tell me a bird flew past my window, I will probably believe you, even though I did not see it myself and I have no evidence. That is because such a thing is likely. I have seen it happen before. It is more likely that a bird flew past my window, than that you are deceiving me. But if you tell me a pig flew past my window, I will not believe you, because my past experience tells me that such things do not happen, and so I presume that what you reported is false. Thus, where there is no evidence we have to rely on our own past experience of the sort of things that really happen (pp. 41-42).

Wednesday, August 10, 2011

Biblical Blasphemy


The following is an article by one of our country's greatest Founding Fathers, Thomas Paine:

The church tells us that the books of the Old and New testament are divine revelation, and without this revelation we could not have true ideas of God.

The Deist, on the contrary, says, that those books are not divine revelation, and that were it not for the light of reason, and the religion of Deism, those books, instead of teaching us true ideas of God, would teach us not only false but blasphemous ideas of him.

Sunday, August 7, 2011

Access To Information Changes Everything


By ThinkTank ~ from EXchristian.net
When people ask, “What made you lose your faith?” it’s always a little challenging to know what to say. How do we compress 5-10 years and 100 reasons into a short response when we really need several hours (or days) to talk about the process of losing our faith?

Visualization of the various routes through a ... 
Partial map of the Internet based on the January 15, 2005 data found on opte.org. Image via Wikipedia

There is also a similar question that ex-christians ask themselves -- “How could I have believed something so improbable for so long?” It turns out, we were far from unintelligent and there is a very good reason why we believed for so long. We did not have access to information.

No Information = Problems
For most of human history, people have had very limited access to information. Most people were dependent on some type of authority for information because it was difficult to find information or to verify things on one’s own. Being dependent on others for information had lots of problems.

It was hard to learn things independently
People were dependent on what other people wrote, taught, said, did, or presented via TV/movies. Even something as simple as looking up the definition of a word meant stopping to find a dictionary. Most people skipped the hassle and learned to be content with ‘not knowing’.