From Alt.Bible.Errancy discussion group, 6-5-99:
TILL
TILL
To begin my response to Goodguy's position that how the apostles' died constitutes evidence of the resurrection, I'm going to post my article "How Did the Apostles Die?" that I published in the July/August 1997 issue of *The Skeptical Review.* It will present general principles that will show the unsoundness of this often-repeated claim. Afterwards, I will address specific points in Goodguy's postings. If he cares to respond, I will, of course, post his responses to the list, but I predict that we won't hear much from him.
*************************
How Did the Apostles Die?
Christian apologists, both real and would-be, argue that the willingness of the apostles to die for their faith is proof that the resurrection of Jesus was a real experience in their lives. People will die for what they *believe* to be true, the argument goes, but they would not die for what they know is *not* true. In this issue (pp. 10-11), Dave Matson has rebutted this argument by showing how that the postresurrection appearances of Jesus could well have been only imaginary or psychological experiences of those who allegedly claimed that they saw Jesus alive after his death. If so, then the apostles who were martyred (if indeed any were) would have died not for what they *knew* to be true but only for what they *thought* they knew was true. There's a big difference.